Comments by "John Walsh" (@johnwalsh4857) on "Binkov's Battlegrounds" channel.

  1. wait...the Russian air force supposedly the 2nd strongest air force in the world...SUPPOSEDLY...Cant achieve superiority against the much smaller Ukrainian air force hahahahah HOW EMBARASSING RUSSIA
    6
  2. My view battle for Gaza ends in mid 2024. with 250K Palestenian casualties, 25K IDF casualties.
    6
  3. well 2023 is the bloodiest year of the war esp. for the Russians, last year same time Dec 29 2022, the Russians suffered 100K casualties. Now the Russians have suffered a total of 360K casualties half of those deaths. in short Russians suffered more than double the casualties of 2022 in 2023. that is very bad. Not surprirsed the Russians have been using human wave meat attacks on fortified Ukrainian positions and getting mowed down. and Im not surprsied the Russians will be continuing this moronic strategy. where pre war the Russian army trained on massive wide sweeping mechanized movement and battles of mobility complete with breakthrus , exploitation and encirclements , now the pathetic Russian army of Dec 29 2023 likes to brag about taking towns and villages in the 20 percent of Ukraine they occupy while they suffer tens of thousands of casualties for every town or village they capture in stupid WW1 style attacks. The Russian army has actually devovled from a modern army to a 1930s Soviet army. commanded by morons trying to emulate stupid failed Soviet generals like Buddyonny and Pavlov. Zhukov and Rokossovky and Konev would be so ashsmed of the Russian army of 2023. Oh and the the frontlines in Ukraine have not changed much since Dec 2022.And the Russian army like to brag its the greatest army in the world and will conquer all of Europe hahahah. Very amusing.
    5
  4. Former Chinese PLA volunteer int he Russian army in Ukraine tells all. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K_jdfaI5dyQ&lc=UgzpDba0K2dvj22WJw54AaABAg
    5
  5. well from what I read, the USA and NATO leadership threatened Russia that if nukes were used in Ukraine then NATO would actually sink the entire Russian black sea fleet for starters and use air power to support Ukrainian troops. and possible NATO troops entering Ukraine and that is just for starters. in addition the following will happne: 1. TOTAL economic sanctions on Russia, if you thought the sanctions right now is bad, they can get much worse. and other countries will be pressured to participate or get the same sanctions 2. Seizure of Russian assets not only by NATO and EU nations and their allies but other countries will be pressured to do the same. Those alone will cause an economic collapse in Russia. and not only that plus massively increased military aid to Ukraine. basically the use of nukes by Russia will make Russia lose the war in Ukraine, Russian military simply cannot stand vs. NATO and even if NATO brings its air power to aid the Ukrainains , it will be a disaster for the Russian military they will lose the war in Ukraine and in the process cause an economic collapse in Russia.
    5
  6. Fro Germany , while they would view WW2 as a success up front , I think behind the scenes overall it would have been a failure for them. the loss of millions of lives and massive amounts of resources and a massive hit on their economy resulted in them gaining Western and Eastern Europe, a large part of North africa, and part of the USSR they did not really gain anything of value. In fact probably after negotiations the Germans would only control the baltic states and half of Ukraine. Their goal of conquering the USSR is a massive failure. Post war, hitler would still remain in power maybe might die in the 50s or 60s. But I dont think Germany would be ready for another push vs. the British and USSR any time soon. too exhausted to do so. Not surprised Germany goes into economic depression mode after the war, and the nazi party after the death of hitler is deposed. and maybe replaced by a coalition of civlian and military leadership.
    5
  7. war between USA and China will be China possibly North Korea vs. USA/Taiwan/Australia/UK/New Zealand/Canada and possibly Japan and South Korea. the Chinese have the largest navy in the world but the CHinese navy while having electronics and sensors approaching the US Navy but the USA is still superior in all aspects, also Chinese ships have poor damage control and sink easilly when damaged.
    5
  8. meaning the UMPK kits are a sign of desperation by the Russians. Not surprised the components are made in China, the Chinese probably sold them the cheapo electronics at big inflated prices.
    5
  9. they are well trained at ....abandoning their vehicles and running away.
    5
  10. this is a good sign Russia has bad manpower issues, I heard Putin wants 150K NKs to fight the Ukrainians yah when Rusisia has to stoop this low to buy NK arty ammo missles and recruits you know the Russians are in trouble. so far since Jan 1 2024 the Russians sufferd 350K casualties and 10K destroyed tanks , APCs IFVs and conquered around .5 percent of Ukraine. 3 months already and the Russians cant kick the Ukrainains out of Kursk. Russian army prestige is down the toilet. and even though Trump coming in manages to get a peace favourable to Russia, it wont feel like victory, it will feel more like a defeat. with Russian economy seriouslyi damaged its military in the shitter, and embarassed fighting a perceived much weaker enemy the Ukrainians and the UKrainains giving the Russians a bloody nose and holding off the Russians for nearly 3 years in a brutal conventional war not seen since WW2. its that bad and embarassing at it has revealed how weak the Russian military really is with a bad combat doctrine corruption and command and control , if it werent for Trump , Russia would lose this war. haha. After the war there will be recriminations and Putin has to purge people since his hold on power will be tenous. the elites will blame him for all their problems .
    5
  11. well here is my take, the Syrians sent thousands of mostly Allawite Shia Syrian troops to Russia to fight in the Ukraine war starting late 2022. from the most loyal units of the Syrian army, where they were treated as cannon fodder and thousands were kaput, these Syrians masqueraded as Russian army troops. So Assad had to fill up his army so he filled it up with local volunteers and of course with Syrian sunni troops and the SUnnis are the majority muslim sect in Syria but the rulers are Shiites. These Sunni troops consituted 75 percent of the Syrian army and the Syrian army was corrupt as hell, sold weapons and even intel to the rebels. also poorly trained, incompetent low morale and the sunnis hated the Assad regime. and the only ones who were effective vs. the rebels were Iranian IRGC and Hezbollah troops and Russian airpower and the thousands of Russian conscripts and hundreds of Russian Spetsnaz and PMC troops who were at the forefront of the fighting and were the most effective troops of the Assad regime, so when the Russians and Iranians withdrew , in the face of the rebel offensive it was game over, Assad's army fell apart in mass desertions and defections and so did the Assad regime.
    4
  12. you mean the Russians hahaah
    4
  13. In a Japanese non surrender, the Soviet invasion of Manchuria and Kuriles will take a lot longer since the Japanese would fight to the death there and they substantial military forces in those areas, also the Soviets would probably postpone the war with Japan until the Americans are fully in Kyushu and wouuld continue to build up their forces in the far east waiting for the Japanese to withdraw military units to the Japanese home islands, not surprised if the Soviets attack after the US invades Honshu in operation coronet in 1946. in the meantime, the Soviets build up their naval assets in the far east , building more landing craft with a plan to invade Hokkaido.
    4
  14. the war in Ukraine shows how incompetent the Russian military leadership is. If they were on the level of the USA. they would have won in 3 days but nope, 3 years and only holding 20 percent of Ukraine. booo hooo.
    4
  15. The west wants to grind down Russia in Ukraine. the longer the war goes the weaker Russia gets. so 8 months into the war Russia is already doing partial mobilization , something not seen since WW2. Russia cannot keep on mobilizing or its risks damaging its economy and provokes unrest. Also the sanctions can get worse later, and sanctions are just slowly grinding down the Russian economy. Also Russia has suffered more than 100,000 casualties in this war, 3K tanks and 6K APCs, number not seen since WW2. This is not just some insurgency like Chechnya or Afghanistan its a real full on conventional war fought with a bit more firepower than WW2. according to Prigozhin, the Ukraine war , the Russians are burning ammo 2X that of the battle of Stalingrad. and makes Chechnya look like kindergarden a walk in the park. The longer Russia is fighitng the war the worse it will be for Russia after the war. I think the Ukrs have to endure 2 years of war, I dont think Russia can keep up the war for 2 more years, Russian people are not the same Russian people of WW2. who were more hardier, and their morale was a lot higher and they were fighting for national survival , here the Russians view this war as a mistake.
    4
  16. I predict after this war is over Putin gone Russia lost , and the chaos in Russia settles down, Russian federation will more or less be intact, however Moscow and the Russian army will be really weak and the puppets of the real powers the RUssian oligarchs and their PMCs who will never allow someone like Putin to become leader. Russian provinces will have a bit more autonomy not only for self rule but also foreign affairs, and they will have their own PMCs. Russia will become a massive decentralized state with its provinces acting like seperate countries but owing fealty to Moscow. Russia will become a massive narco failed state. where anything can happen and become a great game between USA and China EU Turkey, etc. Time of troubles 2.0 is coming back to Russia , and you can all thank Putin for this.
    4
  17. what does that tells us, SU-35s will figure prominently in hte upcoming Russian civil war I predict whatever is left of Russia will still be using hte SU-35 as it main combat plane well into the 22nd century LOL
    4
  18. however while 2023 was in important year 2024 will be the most important year of them all, the USA presidential elections of 2024 will determine on the final outcome of this war, however whether Russia manages to lose this war or gets out a good deal from this war and the Putin regime surviving its economy will still be in ruins, it will still be under bad sanctions, its military much weakened, its economy dangerously on war footing, no more investments from the west, and a worldwide pariah. Russia will have much great difficulty recovering from the war. Im not surprised if Russia experienced a 21st century version of the time of troubles after Putin dies or his removed from power.
    4
  19. not surpirsed after Russia loses this war , the UN may need to deploy peace keeping troops in Russia hahah Russia will become a massive failed state
    4
  20. what is making the difference is the quality of teh soldiers ont he ground, Ukraine, defending, knows its own area and highly motivated. Russians attacking poorly motivated does not know its area of combat. Ukraine is becoming like Winter war 2.0
    4
  21. the Chinese army is even more suckier than the Russian army. hadnt had a major war since 1979 and during that war, the Chinese retreated from Vietnam and claimed it won hahahah
    4
  22.  @hia5235  what war are you in hahhaha. bot
    3
  23. 2023 Russia losing Ukraine has won since 2022
    3
  24. I highly doubt it that China would conquer Taiwan and more Okinawa. any attacks on Japanese territory wil lincur the Japanese coming into the war. Disaster for China.
    3
  25.  @gobomanaga5615  very real wonder why the Russians begged the North Koreans to intervene. and despite Russia being 10X bigger economy and military firepower, Russia has not much expanded beyond 20 percent of Russia it controls. also wonder why 4 months alrady , Russia cant seem to kick Ukraine out of kursk. hmmm.....
    3
  26. syrians also lost lots of tanks during their civil war, using tank rushes without infantry support vs. Syrian guerillas armed with US and Russian ATGMs, that is why the Russians had to ship them lots of replacement T-72s. and had to intervene.
    3
  27.  @JustifyJustin  LOL bot , and I dont really know what you are talking about???
    3
  28.  @Igoryok_travel  no wonder Russian logistics suck
    3
  29.  @timothyreel716  quite true and quite amusing hahaha
    3
  30. after this war is over , the Ukrainian economy will boom due to trillions of USD in investments and reconstruction money and Ukraine being fast tracked to EU and NATO membership much admired by the west as the country who defeated Russia , something NATO leaders have been dreaming of. Meanwhile out of the goodness of their hearts Ukraine might need thousands of Russian refugees escaping from a chaotic Russia to be very low paid janitors, construction workers or maybe the ukrainians will just import foreign workers to do the job since Russians will still be hated in Ukraine. However I do predict many Russian refugee prostitutes will again line the streets of Kaiserstrasse Frankfurt, St. Pauli Hamburg and Pigalle Paris, like the 90s never went out of fashion. Heck you will see many Russian women refugees become human trafficking victims and end up as far as papua new guinea to be hookers. Hey just like the 90s.
    3
  31. why not? 1. lots of ATGMs and artillery to kill massed Russian armor. .2 BTGs not enough to provide security for Russian tanks. 3. Russian logistics is so bad, its cant seem to support massed Russian armor attacks. as shown in the Russian offensives in 2022, when the Russians tried, their logistics fell apart, that is why you have a lot of abandoned Russian armor getting towed by Ukr farmer tractors. 4. no air superiority.6. Poor Russian coordination, training , leadership.
    3
  32.  @АртАрт-к4ж  я старше путина и выгляжу здоровее и красивее
    3
  33. USA, while having stayed out of WW2, it suffered economically with lessened trade, probably the weakest military among the great powers with its military probably on level with a pre war 1941 OTL levels in 1950. Japan is viewed as the biggest threat and tensions with Japan are great esp. with the freezing of Japanese assets in the USA. While the US military is starting to exapnd and rearm it still really underestimates the Japanese military esp. after its poor performance in the border battles with the USSR between 1945-1950. However the USN is woefully unprepared vs. the IJN or Japanese navy which is much stronger than it was in 1941.
    3
  34. In the negotiations , PUtin will threaten to use more chems and maybe even nukes to stop more Ukrainian offensives. They'll claim they used chems since Ukrainians have just invaded Russian territory. or some BS like that.k Putin by this time knows his army is kaput. so wants a face saving reason for peace. with great bitterness. the Ukrs agree to part with the eastern part of the donbass but again Ukraine does not recognize this and Crimea's annexation. Ukraine will still not be part of the EU and NATO however very close cooperation with them. Massive marshal plan trillion dollars at least to repair Ukraine. For Russia, lifting of many sanctions, some still in place due to Russia's occupation of Crimea and East DOnbass. While its back to business as usual, Russia's economy has been badly hurt by the war and sanctions. war scared off the investors. Putin tightens his hold on Russia, scaring millions to leave the country. Europeans really offended by the large scale use of chems by the Russians which not only kills Ukr soldiers but also lots of civilians. boycotts of Russian products worldwide esp. in the 1st world continues. Economic chaos in Russia. China steps in besides lending money to Russia to keep the the Russian economy alive, China starts also getting Russian resources are bargain prices. China also buys a lot of Russian weapon systems , submarines missles etc. However Putin's leadership stops the Chinese from buying off Russian companies. Putin tries to reform the Russian army downsizes it massively tries to make it more professional but this is slow going since Russia has other more pressing matters to attend to. The Russian army has stopped becoming a strong monolithic army to a territorial defense force. Putin probably dies in the next five to ten years. Reputation broken, legacy kaput , Russia is in sort of political chaos first free elections in Russia. Next Russian leadership is more acceptable to the west. However Russian economy while stabilized is still in bad shape, just like the 90s. and with Putin gone. China steps in more, buys up more Russian corporations, extends her influence into Central Asia Caucasus for their very important resources. The war in Ukraine has really been beneficial to China having gotten CHina access to cheap resources , upgraded its weapons tech, not surpirsed CHina hires out Russian scientists to upgrade its weapons systems for a future showdown with the USA. Russia has effectively become a economic vassal to China. Belarus , LUkashenko gone, democratic Belarus gov. which similiar to Ukraine goes heavilly to the west, lots of USA , 1st world investments that fled Russia go into Ukraine and Belarus. Im not surprised after Putin is gone, wih the price of massive economic aid and lifting of the rest of the sanctions, , Russia can agree to have Ukraine and Belarus join the EU but not NATO, probably even Moldova. Giving back Crimea and Donbass are very dicey political topics the Russians will not give those up. Due to the war Russia has lost prestige, and has become a scorned laughingstock. Its oligrachs have also lost a lot since the west sequestered confiscated a lot of their assets due to the massive use of Chemical weapons by the Russians.
    3
  35.  @MrLu4o  heck I will be nostradamus of the 21st century.
    2
  36.  @MrLu4o  you will obe one of the refugeees streaming to the EU from Russia sorry we have too many refugees already.
    2
  37. In the Korean war, the North Korean army performed much better than the Russian army in the Ukraine war, the NKs conquered 90 percent of the country before being pushed all the way back to the Chinese border , the Russians meanwhile only captured 40 percent of Ukraine from Feb to mid 2022 while getting pushed back to 15 percent of UKraine in late 2022. Embarassing for Russia having a supposedly much weaker Ukrainian military reconquer 50 percent of its lost territories in late 2022, I esp. found it hilarious 3 whole Russian XXs collapsed in Eastern Ukraine and the Russians soldiers ran back to Russia using stolen Ukrainian cars and bicycles hahaha and left 450 tanks abandoned many intact hahahah and Izyum and Khkerson has still not been recaptured by the Russians ....embarassing for a supposed superpower called Russia to not only beg the NKs for help but also say that they are actually fighting NATO soldiers not Ukrainians . the cope is that bad in Russia hahahaah
    2
  38. these days with the state of the Russian army, even Poland can defeat the Russian army (without nukes and chems of course).
    2
  39.  SaintFluffySnow  really I know it full well, and so far Russia has the manpower but the will to fight sucks bad. Ukrainians still havfe a strong will to fight. Russia will lose this war of attrition. its not even the population its the economy
    2
  40. After this war is over, Russians cannot anymore use the Great patriotic war 1941 to 1945 to justify everything they do. cant use it as a crutch anymore all you Russians can thank Putin for this.
    2
  41. when the Russians start using chemical weapons en masse that will produce such an outrage the west will provide not only tanks, but ATACMs, even jets. and total sanctions on Russia, and any other nation supporting it. if it graduates to nuclear, possible war with NATO.
    2
  42. If Russia invaded Ukraine , Russia would lay Warsaw under siege but that is about as far as Russia goes before bogging down, and NATO will respond massively. I think NATO would have rolled Russia back by now and the war will end.
    2
  43. The Polish army can capture Moscow the way the Russian army is performing these days.
    2
  44. its amazing that the Ukrs were able to punch thru Russian defenses at Robotyne without air support, the Southern Front is a disaster for the Russians, who are suffering from supply and manpower shortages esp. in artillery and artillery ammo, its so bad that the Ukrs actually have artillery superiority over the Russians in the Southern Front. since the Ukrs are very effectively targetting Russian logistics and artillery with HMARS, JDAMs and cluster munitions which have destroyed a lot of Russian artillery. Russians are desperately shipping more men and artillery to Robotyne try to stop the Ukrs but these are getting interdicted by the Ukr HAMRS and JDAMs. the other fronts have seen Russian diversionary attacks esp. at Kupiansk but all failures. in fact the Bakhmut front is shaping to be a disaster for the Russians as the Ukrs have retaken all the high ground and are encircling the Russian defenders there, supposedly Putin has ordered the Russian defenders at Bakhmut to fight to the death hahahha. I can see the Ukrs going as far as capturing Tokmak and even Bakhmut by Oct 2023. and while the Ukr offensive would be seen as a failure its actually a success, as they would have captured Tokmak at important transportation hub in the area but also Bakhmut for politicla reasons, the Ukr recapture of Bakhmut woulud alone be a political disaster for Putin. Also I think an even more significant blow to Putin would be the loss of massive amoutns of Russian casualties, vehicles and resources. Im not surprised Putin would be forced to do another mobilization heck he may even declare the special military operation a real war. I expect a Russian winter offensive to try to recapture Tokmak. Ukraine is winning by further weakening Putin's political standing. Heck you will probably see another coup vs. Putin after the Ukr recapture of Bakhmut.
    2
  45. from what I heard Ukrs drones are sent in swarms, and vs. tanks they hit them with several drones, from the top, tank is toast.
    2
  46.  @AdotLOM  hahaha more funny comparisons, from Russian bots , yah Russia is just doing fine bro according to you and you always harp back to Afghanistan hahahaha. Very funny hey Russkies how about SYRIA hahahahah I heard Assad wants to divorce his wife since the wife wants to go to London since Moscow is so shit.
    2
  47.  @puzzled012  sorry the Russian military in 2022 is probably a lot more inefficent than the USSR of 1945, heck probalby even moire inefficient than the USSR of 1940. its that bad
    2
  48. There will be another war between China and the USA in the next 20 years. or even longer. In the decades post Ukr war. there will be two strong power blocs forming to oppose the USA and EU blocs, teh Chinese and Muslim blocs. The Chinese bloc will be made up of Mongolia, new countries in former Russian fed territories in Central Asia, Siberia and Far east , as well as established countires in Central Asia. and the Muslim bloc made up of Muslim countries all over the world including Turkey, Indonesia, Malaysia, most of the middle east, the new countries of the former Russian fed Caucasus Iran and Central Asia. There will be a reconcillation between Iran and Saudi Arabia. These two will ally and Challenge the USA and European hegemony by the 2050s. The future war between these power blocs will be the worst the world has ever seen. world war 3 with the war reaching into outer space. Probably happen in the 2070s.
    2
  49. what will end, when one side gives in, Im thinking economic collapse or Putin dies or unrest in Russia. Or maybe the Russians use nukes. What Im sure of, the Russians cant conquer the whole of Ukraine anymore and they have problems keeping what they already have.
    2
  50. yah urban warfare is a battle of firepower and tactics. slow steady methodical with lots of firepower is the way to go , rushing in is stupid and suicidal. The IDF has a massive advantage in terms of firepower compared to Hamas.
    2