Comments by "John Walsh" (@johnwalsh4857) on "Ukraine’s war is an orchestra - and its generals conduct operational art | Defence in Depth" video.

  1. yep to judge the state of this war, Russian took about 40 percent of Ukraine from Feb to April 2022, since then the Ukrs retook 50 percent of what they lost so the Russians in Sept 28 2023 , 1.5 years later control only 20 percent of Ukraine, noting the Russians did a surprise attack on Ukraine, Russians outnumbers the Ukrs in terms of manpower, and has fire power superiority a much larger air force and 10X the manpower reserves and economy to that of Ukraine. The Ukrainians are retaking lost territory and inflicting bruising Russian casualties and equpment losses. and retaking them without much air support. So Ukrainians general ship I can say is much better than the Russian one. Chalk all this up to Much better Ukrainians generalship , superior Ukrainian leadership, training, coordination , flexibility, improvisation morale , motivation is simply defeating the Russians.
    4
  2. After this war is over , Ukrainian generals will be much studied and admired is world military schools and history books, the Russian counterparts will be laughed considered to be hilariously bad sub par generals. If compared to ww2 generals, Ukrainians generals would be compared to Pattons, , the Russian ones would be compared to Soviet generals Budyonny, Kulik Pavlov
    3