Hearted Youtube comments on Max Murphy (@maxmurphyxyz) channel.

  1. I think an important point Graeber makes in the book is the degree to which actual jobs only exist to support BS jobs. Janitorial work is real work. But what if the janitor position only exists because a massive office building full of BS jobs take place there? If we were to remove the BS jobs, we may very well not need that janitor anymore. How many fast food workers only exist because people working BS jobs are too tired or demotivated to cook after work, and so get take out instead? Graeber even takes it a step further to suggest that (and this can require some imagination) many jobs that may not be classified as BS jobs are ultimately doing harm to society, but in the service of capital? How much more free time might we all have if the profit motive did not run at the core of every single private enterprise's goals. How many less nurses and doctors would we need to work if we all had more time to take care of our health? How many fewer restaurants we would we need if everyone had more time to cook their own meals at home? How many fewer maintenance jobs would exist if we stopped constructing and maintaining the private property that creates said bullshit jobs? There's no way to find an exact quantity of any of these questions, they are all dialectical in nature, that is to say, the way society would change would change and it can be nearly impossible to predict with quantifiable certainty, how. But I am certainly interested. Also as an aside, it's really tragic Graeber was not around to give his commentary on the state of the job market during and following the covid lockdowns. I think he would have felt quite vindicated.
    275
  2. 251
  3. 162
  4. 150
  5. 144
  6. I "worked" as a technician- essentially a scientist who does the actual work of senior scientists. I worked at many different companies, and the job was almost always the same. I did the work, year after year, and the senior people got paid for it. If something didn't pan out, usually due to the insane ideas some of those who handed ME their work to do, it somehow was MY fault, not the fault of those passing on the actual labor of their work. Because I and my fellow coworker techs were on the low end of the totem pole, we were watched like prisoners in a jail. We weren't in charge of our own work, and we weren't allowed to do anything ourselves, so we played the 'busy' game about 3 out of every 5 days. Meanwhile, the upper level scientists- many of whom had the same education the techs had- usually walked around all day talking about bullshit, not doing much of anything or maybe watching YouTube most of the day, and they were paid at least 5X as much as we were. I was so disgusted with it that after I was laid off- again- due to 'economic conditions' I changed career paths entirely into high-tech manufacturing, thinking it would be different. Now, its the same thing, but instead of scientists its engineers and low-to-mid-level management. I hate the US job market, and the only thing I now have to look forward to is going to sleep every night. Do yourself a favor and NEVER EVER work for anyone else. Start your own company and NEVER look back. Modern employment is slavery, pure and simple.
    123
  7. 116
  8. 93
  9. 83
  10. 80
  11. 67
  12. 62
  13. 60
  14. 47
  15. 45
  16. 40
  17. 27
  18. 25
  19. 20
  20. 20
  21. 19
  22. 19
  23. 15
  24. 15
  25. 14
  26. 14
  27. 13
  28. 12
  29. 12
  30. 11
  31. 10
  32. 10
  33. 10
  34. 10
  35. 8
  36. 8
  37. 8
  38. 8
  39. 8
  40. 8
  41. 8
  42. 7
  43. 7
  44. 7
  45. 7
  46. 7
  47. 6
  48. 6
  49. 6
  50. 5